TRIAL RESULTS

 

Type of Action:  Claim of negligent repair/maintenance against a local 

heating and air conditioning contractor.

Injuries Alleged:  Fuel Oil Spill - Contamination of residential property 

with remediation costs in excess of $150,000.00.

Court:  Circuit.     County:  Lapeer.

Judge:  Honorable Nick O. Holowka.

Trial Verdict:  No cause for action (no negligence).

Attorney for Defendant:  Jeffrey C. Collison.

___________________________________________________________________

Type of Action:  Third-party automobile accident with claim for

non-economic damages.

Injuries Alleged:  Neck and right shoulder.  Massive rotator cuff tear with 

decompensation; temporary exacerbation of the degenerative arthritis of the 

cervical spine; mild radiculitis of the right arm; and carpal tunnel syndrome.

Court:  Circuit.    County:  Bay.

Judge:  Honorable Kenneth W. Schmidt.

Trial Verdict:  No cause for action. (No proximate cause).

Attorney for Defendant:  Jeffrey C. Collison.

___________________________________________________________________

Type of Action:  Uninsured motorist claim for non-economic damages.

Injuries Alleged:  Compression fracture of the cervical spine with 

ligament injury.

Court:  Circuit.     County:  Saginaw.

Judge:  Honorable Lynda L. Heathscott.

Trial Verdict:  No cause for action.  Plaintiff was more than 50% 

comparatively negligent.

Attorney for Defendant:  Jeffrey C. Collison.

___________________________________________________________________

Type of Action:  Third-party automobile claim for non-economic 

 damages.

 Injuries alleged:  Death of a 15 year old pedestrian.

 Court:  Circuit.    County:  Saginaw.

 Judge:  Leopold Borrello.

 Trial Verdict:  No cause for action (no negligence).

 Attorney for Defendant:  Jeffrey C. Collison.

___________________________________________________________________

Type of Action:  Third-party automobile claim for economic and 

non-economic damages.

Injuries alleged:  Herniated cervical discs; closed head injury, post 

traumatic stress disorder; low back; carpal tunnel syndrome - bilateral; 

and bilateral shoulder (two arthroscopic surgeries).  It was claimed 

that the injuries resulted in a serious impairment of body function which 

restricted Plaintiff's ability to lead a normal life.

Court:  Circuit  County:  Saginaw.

Judge:  Robert Kaczmarek.

Trial Verdict:  No Cause For Action with the Jury finding "no negligence" 

due to the existence of a sudden emergency.

Attorney for Defendant:  Jeffrey C. Collison.

______________________________________________________________

Type of Action:  Third-party automobile claim for non-economic damages.
Injuries alleged:  Right knee injury resulting in permanent bursitis, arthritis 

and constant pain, Treatment consisted of pain medication, physical therapy, 

cortisone injections and the use of a leg immobilizer.  It was claimed that the 

injury resulted in a serious impairment of body function which restricted 

Plaintiff's ability to lead a normal life.  Severe bruising was sustained and a 

photograph was shown to the Jury.
Court:  Circuit     County:  Saginaw     
Judge:  Patrick M. Meter.
Trial Verdict:  No Cause For Action with the Jury finding "no negligence".
Attorney for Defendant:  Daniel G. Collison.
_______________________________________________________________ 

Type of Action:  Third-party automobile claim.
Injuries Alleged:  Closed-head injury.
Court:  Circuit     County:  Saginaw
Judge:  Robert Kaczmarek.
Trial Verdict:  No Cause For Action.
Attorney for Defendant:  Joseph T. Collison.
_______________________________________________________________

Type of Action:  Third-party No-Fault.
Injuries Alleged:  Two-inch scar over left eye.
Court:  Circuit     County:  Bay
Judge:  Lawrence M. Bielawski.
Trial Verdict:  No Cause For Action with the Jury finding "no permanent 

serious disfigurement".
Attorney for Defendant:  Joseph T. Collison.
_______________________________________________________________

Type of Action:  Third-party No-Fault
Injuries Alleged:  Chronic myositis initially induced by trauma.
Court:  Circuit     County:  Saginaw
Judge:  Leopold P. Borrello
Trial Verdict:  No Cause For Action with the Jury finding No serious 

impairment of a body function.
Attorney for Defendant:  Charles C. Collison, Jr.
 _________________________________________________________________________________________

Type of Action: Third-Party – Personal Injury

Injuries Alleged: Fractured left clavicle, aggravation of intermuscular 

nodule fascitis requiring excision. (Claimed serious impairment of body 

function/permanent serious disfigurement).

Court: 34th Judicial Circuit  County: Ogemaw 

Judge: Michael J. Baumgartner

Trial Verdict: No Cause of Action - no negligence.

Attorney for Defendant: Charles C. Collison, Jr.

__________________________________________________________________________________________

Type of Action: Third-Party - Personal Injury

Injuries Alleged:  Broken right thumb; injured tendon.

Court: 10th Judicial Circuit  County:  Saginaw

Judge:  Leopold P. Borrello

Trial Verdict:  No Cause For Action - no negligence. 

Attorney for Defendant: Charles C. Collison, Jr.